Hatam Boostani^1*, Seyed Mohamad Hoseini², Negar Khodadadi³ and Najmeh Froozi³

¹Psychiatry Group, Psychiatrist, Ahvaz Jundishapur University of Medical Sciences, Ahvaz, ^{Iran. 2}Department of Radiation and oncology of Gholestan University Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Ahvaz Jundishapur University of Medical Sciences, Ahvaz, Iran. ³School of Medicine, Ahvaz Jundishapur University of Medical Sciences, Ahvaz, Iran.

DOI : https://dx.doi.org/10.13005/bpj/881

Abstract

Marital satisfaction is a multidimensional concept and depends on many factors. Breast cancer is the most common cancer specific to one part of the body in women and the leading cause of death due to malignancy in women of 40 to 44. Breasts are a symbol of femininity, when they are lost due to cancer treatment or there is transformation in them, in addition to physical pain, psychological burden on the patients will be significant. This study was performed on 50 patients with breast cancer referring to the radiotherapy clinic of Golestan Hospital in Ahvaz. Patients were divided into two groups (n=25) patients with mastectomy and breast conserved patients. Data were collected through interviews and 47-item Enrich marital satisfaction questionnaire. The data were analyzed using SPSS15. The statistical level of p <0.05 was considered as statistically significant level. A comparison of the relationship between marital satisfaction and the elapsed time between mastectomy and breast-conserved groups showed that with increase of time in the mastectomy group, the level of marital satisfaction reduced.

Keywords

Mastectomy; Marital satisfaction; Breast conservation

Download this article as: 

Copy the following to cite this article: Boostani H, Hoseini S. M, Khodadadi N, Froozi N. Marital Satisfaction in Women with Breast Cancer: A Comparison between Mastectomy and Breast Conserved patients. Biomed Pharmacol J 2015;8(2)

Copy the following to cite this URL: Boostani H, Hoseini S. M, Khodadadi N, Froozi N. Marital Satisfaction in Women with Breast Cancer: A Comparison between Mastectomy and Breast Conserved patients. Biomed Pharmacol J 2015;8(2). Available from: http://biomedpharmajournal.org/?p=6210

Introduction

Marital satisfaction is influenced by different factors, the collection of which results in marital satisfaction (1-5). Marital life quality may be the first thing that women are concerned aboutwhen they are diagnosed with breast cancer. Mastectomy results in the loss of an important part of a woman’s body and this causes a loss of confidence and a sense of charm in the patients (6-9,3). The main advantage for women with breast cancer is breast conservation and preservation of the body form (10,11).

There are common signs of anxiety and depression in patients with cancer. This mental turmoil has impacts on healthy sexual performance and can be a significant problem for patients. Patients with higher levels of psychological distress experienceextra sexual dysfunction (12-16). Decreased physical performance, lack of sleep, fatigue, loss of appetite, pain associated with psychological distress, each of which can affect sexual desire (17-20).

The results of a study that examined the relationship between social interaction and marital satisfaction showed that people who are dissatisfied with their lives are unable to maintain satisfactory relationships outside the family and tends to isolation and loneliness and depression (21). The results showed significant differences in body image, self-esteem and feelings of attractiveness in mastectomy patients in comparison of before and after surgery (22). Today, the conservative surgery for breast cancer in which the breast tissue is only partly taken out is an acceptable method, but is used limitedly. The statistical survey showed that only 20% of general surgeons used a conservative approach, and the rest preferred mastectomy (11).

Given the high rate of incidence of breast cancer and mastectomy and treatment effect on marital satisfaction, and also the fact that so far not many reviews are conducted about it, especially in Iran, the present research studied and compared marital satisfaction in patients with breast cancer in two groups the ones who underwent breast-conserving surgery and the mastectomy group. Understanding this relationship helps the family and doctors to increase the satisfaction of patients in normal life, especially given the impact of treatment on their marital relationship.

Materials and Methods

The study conducted was an epidemiologic analytical study that assessed the life satisfaction in 50 married women with breast cancer compared in two groups with mastectomy and breast conservation. Patients aged from 20 to 55. Enrich questionnaire developed in 1989 in America to identify areas of strength to evaluate potential prolific and productive problemsrelationship, modified in Iran by Soleimanian (1994) as a shorter form with 47 questions, including 12 sub-scale was used. In thisquestionnaire,nine subscales (personal issues, marital communication, conflict resolution, financial management, leisure events, sex, marriage and children, relatives and friends, and religious orientation) were evaluated.

To examine the findings of the investigation descriptive statistics and to examine the differences between the groups inferential statistics (t test) were used. Data analysis was performed using SPSS17.

Results

The relationship of marital satisfaction and breast cancer was evaluated in patients with breast cancer in two groups with breast conservation and mastectomy. Moreover, marital satisfaction sub-scales were calculated and compared between two groups. All statistical calculations were done with the help of SPSS17, and statistical level P <0.05 was considered as statistically significant level.

Tables 1 and 2 indicate descriptive research findings in breast conservation and mastectomy groups, is these two groups, common life satisfaction score (based on Enrichquestionnaire), the scores ofmarital satisfaction subscales (based on Enrichquestionnaire) and age of sickness were calculated.

Table 1: Descriptive findings in patients with breast conservation

Scale	Average X	Standard deviation 3d	Minimum	Maximum	number of samples (n)
Personality issues	15.96	4.54	9	25	25
Marital relationship	16.44	3.94	9	25	25
Conflict Resolution	17.24	3.44	12	25	25
Financial Management	18.32	3.55	9	25	25
Free time	17.36	3.77	9	23	25
Sex	17.80	3.52	11	23	25
Marriage and children	18.8	3.91	10	25	25
Family and Friends	17.32	2.86	14	21	25
Religious orientation	19.36	3.09	3	25	25
Sickness age	23.88	17.47	113	72	25
Marital Satisfaction	157.88	22.95	113	211	25

The average time spent from the treatment was 23.88 months. Average marital satisfaction in this group was 157.88that based on Enrich questionnaire showsmedium and satisfaction of marital relationship of spouses.

Table 2: Descriptive results in mastectomy patients

Scale	Average X	Standard deviation 3d	Minimum	Maximum	number of samples (n)
Personality issues	15.48	4.38	8	25	25
Marital relationship	15.92	4.81	8	25	25
Conflict Resolution	17.16	4.66	7	23	25
Financial Management	17.84	4.12	11	24	25
Free time	17.76	3.86	10	23	25
Sex	17.92	4.20	9	24	25
Marriage and children	18.8	4.29	5	25	25
Family and Friends	17.60	3.5	10	24	25
Religious orientation	19.32	3.92	11	24	25
Sickness age	28.2	25.97	6	96	25
Marital Satisfaction	157.08	28.33	89	201	25

In this group,the elapsed time from start of treatment was about 28.2 months. The average marital satisfaction scores in mastectomy group was 157.08, which represents the average satisfaction of marital relationship of spouses.

Research variables were compared. The results of this comparison in Table 3, where subscales of marital satisfaction in both groups has been shown, demonstrated that there was no significant difference between the two groups in any of subscales and there is no difference between the subscales of marriage and children between the two groups.

Table 3: Comparison of research variables

Variables compared	T	dt	sin	Mean difference
Personality issues	0.38	48	0.7	0.48
Marital relationship	0.42	48	0.67	0.52
Conflict Resolution	0.06	48	0.68	0.52
Financial Management	0.44	48	0.66	0.48
Free time	0.37-	48	0.71	0.4-
Sex	0.2-	48	1	0.12-
Marriage and children	0	48	1	0
Family and Friends	0.31-	48	0.76	0.28-
Religious orientation	0.04	48	0.97	0.04
Marital Satisfaction	0.11	48	0.91	0.8
Sickness age	0.69-	48	0.49	4.32-

Marital satisfaction sub-scales were compared in the two groups and there was no significant difference between the two groups.Table 4 shows the correlation between the variables used in the study and the results of the relationship between marital satisfaction and the elapsed time from the start of treatment in the breast conservation group. In this study, there was no significant correlation between these two variables.

Table 4: The correlation between the variables used in the study in patients with breast preservation

Correlated variables	The correlation coefficient	Significance level	Number of samples
Sickness age and marital satisfaction	0.34	0.09	25

By increase the elapsed time from start of treatment (sickness age) marital satisfaction did not change, i.e., there was no difference between age and marital satisfaction in the breast conservation group.

The relationship between marital satisfaction and the elapsed time from start of treatment in the mastectomy group is shown in Table 5. The results of this study showed that by increase in the elapsed time from disease, marital satisfaction decreased.

Table 5: The correlation between the variables used in the study in mastectomy patients

Correlated variables	The correlation coefficient	Significance level	Number of samples
Sickness age and marital satisfaction	-0.149	0.01	25

Based on these results, in the mastectomy group marital satisfaction decreased with increasing age of sickness (P <0.05).

Discussion and Conclusion

Breast conservation group had moderate status in marital satisfaction. Reduction of this measure can be due to fatigue caused by chronic therapy and chemotherapy effects (fatigue, nausea, etc.).

In interviews, many people said that, the majority of family income is devoted to their treatment. Due to the high costs of treatment, the patient’s expectation level reduced and was satisfied about how the family spends.

In previous studies, including the study of Norder Center, breast cancer was considered as a risk factor for sexual relations, as well as the study conducted at Georgia University breast cancer had reduced sexual understanding and sexual attraction (6,11). In theNorder study, reduction of sexual activity in patients with breast cancer was with increased supportive role of their spouses, in this study, patients did not have more problems than the control group (6). Group mastectomy in marital satisfaction sub-scale was moderate.

Feeling bad body shape, costs and consequences of the disease treatment can be effective in reducing the satisfaction with level and type of relation. Both groups had high satisfaction in the area of financial management, due to the heavy costs of chemotherapy and surgery, most patients felt gratitude towards their spouses, and expectations about the rest of their household income had decreased. In religious orientation the mastectomy group had high satisfaction.

It is justified according to the culture of our society and that many people have religious beliefs. Marital satisfaction in the mastectomy group was 157.08, which indicates the relative and average satisfaction with marital relations by the spouses. In the study conducted in NorderCenter, despite the decline in sexual relations, the role of spousal support had increased and on the whole, breast cancer was considered as a risk factor for relations between the spouses.

Mastectomy and breast conservation groups had no differences in subscales of marriage and children. This can be the result of the culture of our society, and that the children have a key role in the lives of Iranian families and are often of couple’s priorities of thought,so that even the disease, such as pain due to disease and other problems caused by breast cancer treatment costs do not affect the thinking and practice of parents towards their children. Moreover, often the couples agree in the care of their children and the importance of children in the family.

The main objective of this study was to investigate the relationship between mastectomy and breast-conserving surgery in the marital satisfaction in patients with breast cancer. The results of the survey data showed that there is no significant difference between the two groups in of breast conservation and mastectomy in the rate of marital satisfaction.

These results were similar to the results of study by Bokovic (19). In this study, the type of surgery had no effect on marital satisfaction and sexual compatibility. In examining relationships between couples in the study by Bokovic, the sense of satisfaction from sexual life in breast cancer patients fell after surgery in both groups, but there was no significant difference between the two groups. The results for the difference between the two groups areconsistent with this study.

The results of this study showed that,there was no relationship between marital satisfaction and the time elapsed since the disease. This means that by increasing the elapsed time from illness, marital satisfaction did not change. Also checking out the results of the comparison between marital satisfaction and the elapsed time of the mastectomy surgery showed that, with increasing elapsed time of surgery, marital satisfaction decreased in mastectomy group.

This can be due to the reduced spousal support after the passage of time. At the start of the sickness, factors such as pity increase the attention and support of the spouses, but gradually over time, given that breast is an important organ in sexual relations, the createdsexual dysfunction decreases marital satisfaction. In the mentioned study, sexual performance, satisfaction with marital life, a sense of sexuality, body image, quality of life and marital satisfaction have been surveyedwhere most problems during had been during the first months after the operation andreduced over time.These results are justified because immediately after surgery,there are the problems such as pain from surgery, the stress of dealing with the disease, and, over time, the increase of understanding of the patients from the disease can help reduce the problems.

In a study at the University of Georgia that was done during one year (21) with the passage of time, sexual problems had decreased, but increased in total before the operation. In the present study, the most time passed of the sickness was about 6 years that was longer than in the studyat Georgia University, which could be the reason of difference in the results. The main objective of the project was comparing marital satisfaction in breast cancer patients with breast conservation and mastectomy andthere is no significant relationship between the two groups (Table 3). Of the implications of the findings is delivering results to health care officials as a strategy to select the best type of procedure in relation to the treatment of patients with breast cancer.

References

1. Aghamohammadian, HR (2003). Investigating the relationship between personality characteristics and satisfaction in women University of Mashhad.
2. Shamaei, A. Comparing marital satisfaction and mental health and the relationship between these two variables in employed and unemployed women in Ahvaz. For Masters 2005
3. Break Jonathan, gynecological Nowak 2002 Translation Dictionary Bigvand SH, Faridian Iraq Delara, Malekalaei Mohsen, Tehran next generation, 182 hypocrisy, thirteenth edition, 207-307
4. Shafiabadi AS, Naseri, G, Theories of counseling and psychotherapy. University Centre, 1999
5. Golmohammadi, P. The Relationship between job stress and mental health of Khuzestan Steel Industry staff. Thesis in Industrial and Organizational Psychology.
6. Wood JD,Tombrink J.Impact of cancer on sexuality and self-image:a group program for paitient and partners.Soc Word Health Care 1998:4.
7. Stig Chan, the treatment of chronic pelvic giving step by step in the diagnosis and treatment of an illness, translation Roghaei Muhammad Ali Akbari, Mohammad Rahim, the first edition of the publication Manny 1999.79
8. Hinnen C, Hagedoorn M, Ranchor AV, Sanderman R. Relationship satisfaction in women: a longitudinal case-control study about the role of breast cancer, personal assertiveness, and partners’ relationship-focused coping.. Norther Center for Heather Research, University of Groningen, The Netherlands.S.C.hinnen @ Medo umegonl. Br J Health Psychol. 2008 Nov;13(Pt 4):737-54. Epub 2007 Nov 12
9. Onen sertoz O, Elbi Mete H, noyan A,Alpor M, Kapkac m.To examin the effects of surgery type on body image, sexuality, self-steam and marital adjustment, and to determine the most frequent sexual dysfunction seen among breast cancer survivors. Turk psikivatr Derg.2004 winter; 15(4):264-75
10. Schag CAC,Genz PA,Polinsky ML,et al.Characteristics of women at risk for psychosocial distress in the year after cancer.J Clin Oncol 1999;11;783.
11. Najafi M, Hashemi ES. Ebrahimi, M. Kaviani, A. Studying the performance of general surgeons in different methods of surgical treatment of breast conservative surgery or mastectomy University of Medical Sciences Summer 2006
12. Jani Ghorbani.M,Fadaii.S.Medical university,Study of effect of cognitive behavioral counseling on body image alteration in woman undergone mastectomy,Iranian journal of cancer prevention.ISCP,Vols,Suppl,Feb 2008,page28
13. Soo KC,Wong CY,Hoe AL,Lim J5. Sexuality of women after mastectomy. – Sep;24(5):659-63, 1995 Sep;24(5):659-63
14. Bukovic ‘D, fajdic J, Hrgovic Z, Kaufmann M, Hojsak I, Stanceric T. Sexual dysfunction in breast cancer survivors. Dpartmant of obstetrics and Genicology, University Hospital Center Zagreb, Cratia.
15. Aghaberavi, M. Mahmoud Ahmedi, F. Muhammadi, I, Veravani Farahani, A. University of teacher training college.
16. Burwell, Stephanie R., et al. “Sexual problems in younger women after breast cancer surgery.” Journal of Clinical Oncology 24.18 (2006): 2815-2821.
17. Soo KC,Wong CY,Hoe AL,Lim J5. Sexuality of women after mastectomy. – Sep;24(5):659-631995 Sep;24(5):659-63
18. Gans PA,Desmond EA, Belin TR, Meyerowitz BE, Rowland JH, Predictors of sexual health in woman after breast cancer diagnoseis.J Clin Oncolol1983;17:283
19. Andrykowski MA,Crran SL,Lighner R Off-treatment fatigue in breast cancer survivors:a controlled comparision.J behave Med 1998,21:1
20. Fobair P, Stewart SL, Chang S, D’Onofrio C, Banks PJ, Bloom JR. Body image and sexual problems in young women with breast cancer. Stanford University, USA. pfobair@stanford.edu 2006 Jul;15(7):579-94.
21. Amman Allahi Fard, A. Investigating the relationship between personality traits and individual and family factors and marital satisfaction among employees of government offices in Ahwaz. For Masters 2005.
22. Vincen T Devita,Jr,MD Samuel Hellman,MD Stefeven A.Reosenberg,MD,PHD cancer principles and practice of oncology 2002.volum 2,chapter 37,page 3039

(Visited 807 times, 1 visits today)